By Joyell Arvella
“We die. That may be the meaning of life. But we do language. That may be the measure of lives.”
—Toni Morrison
It’s hard to believe that at one point in recent history, a person did not choose to become a midwife. That decision was made by the traditional midwife in their blood or extended family.
This is because walking the path of a midwife required much responsibility – physically and spiritually.
The inherent scope of traditional midwifery demands a strong understanding of nature’s cycles, human physiology, and how the two concepts reinforce each other.
It’s important to note that the term “midwife” is a fairly new addition to many Indigenous languages for the Global Majority. In ancient times, the people known for catching babies were given titles that loosely translated to healer, medicine woman, being from the moon, guardian of the veil, and godparent.
Prior to Western colonization, these titles were not freely given to every person. Only the most trusted and skilled matriarchs to handle birth, life, and death were regarded as what we now call “midwives.” Hence, choosing the next daughter, granddaughter, or niece to inherit that title was taken seriously. That all changed with the cultural pillaging, genocide, and enslavement our midwives endured for hundreds of years, caused by manifest destiny, imperialism, and capitalism.
Fast forward to the Reconstruction Era redefining the rights of formerly enslaved people and their descendants in the United States. This era ushered in the crumbling of the preferred social caste order in America of white dominance.
The late nineteenth century into the early twentieth century reinforced racial segregation, medical and vigilante violence against Black, Indigenous, and immigrant people, and eugenic laws that determined that only the people with “most desirable genes” would be allowed to reproduce in the U.S. mainland and its occupied territories, Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Virgin Islands.
During this same time, lawmakers passed laws such as the Sheppard-Towner Act, restricting the scope of practice and credibility of traditional midwives under the guise of reducing infant and maternal mortality. In actuality, this act, coupled with eugenic practices and Jim Crow era, disrupted the livelihood of Black traditional midwives and the communities they served. The infant mortality rates were the lowest when births were attended by Black midwives. The infant and maternal rates were highest in hospital settings due to white doctors and nurses not using proper hygiene practices during birth and not understanding physiological birth.
Within one generation, community autonomy over how traditional midwives cared for their communities, and their credibility as safer health providers was legislated away.
Instead of spending decades at the feet of elder Black women who selected them, the younger generations had to learn about birth (and death) in formal institutions and earn licensure if they wanted to be licensed midwives in their communities.
The new laws did not stop elder traditional midwives from passing on their wisdom about birth, death, nature, and spiritual practices to their children and grandchildren.
I am one of those great-granddaughters.
Adapting Spiritual Practices
For our Black and Indigenous traditional midwives, their relationships with birth and death evolved from helping our villages thrive, whether through ceremonies or supporting our neighborhoods in surviving state-sanctioned violence.
Many of our midwives responded to the prevalence of unpredictable death and violence by adapting their ancestral nature and spiritual practices to create systems such as Hoodoo, Louisiana Voodoo, Candomblé, Lukumi, and Obeah. These spiritual systems alchemized nature for safe births, healing, deaths, and protection. Our midwives understood how to not be fearful of death while also not welcoming death to their front doors.
The Black and Indigenous midwives of the Lowcountry’s St. Helena Island come to mind.
I just returned from hosting a week-long birth worker residency on the island. During our time, we sat at the feet of a community matriarch who is preserving the legacy of Granny Midwives. She shared that at one time, St. Helena Island was made up entirely of plantations. Every square inch of the island’s soil had fresh drops of blood, sweat, and violence. Rather than be consumed by the prospect of death, these traditional midwives resorted to developing their midwifery skills to support babies that choose to stay earthside, while simultaneously secretly passing on their spiritual practices, remedies, and symbols to the one with “second sight.”
The Babies Born En Caul Had Already Met Death
How a person was born, and in some cases their placenta, revealed a lot about their purpose.
Those born with the “second sight” were babies born en caul, or veiled, meaning the placenta membranes did not break prior to their birth, or they were born with a piece of the membranes covering their face.
Babies born en caul or veiled were said to be “born to sit at the crossroads” because the amniotic sac could have easily suffocated the baby before it could take a deep breath. Veiled and en caul put babies at a crossroad to decide if they wanted to live or transition. These babies were thought to get close to death without death taking them, thus giving them a second sight into the spiritual world.
Many of these second sight babies became community healers and/or were selected to be the next traditional midwives because of their unique relationship to birth and death.
Remembrance Through Embodiment
Traditional midwives were intentional about only selecting the person in their family who they believed had the mental capacity and spiritual insights to sit at the crossroads of birth and death.
As we just celebrated Fet Gede, Dia de los Muertos, and All Saints Day, I encourage birth workers to examine their relationships to birth and death. What are your beliefs and fears? What are your specific gifts to celebrate both? What have you inherited from the traditional midwives who came before you? More importantly, who has chosen you to do this work?
Joyell Arvella, JD (she/her), is a 4th-generation descendant of traditional midwives. She began her midwifery journey 22 years ago and has since explored birth traditions in 20+ countries. Joyell is currently a National State of Birth Justice Fellow with the National Association to Advance Black Birth and Elephant Circle. She is completing a MEAC-accredited program to become a CPM while supporting communities as a reproductive justice advocate, medicine woman, and writer. While she no longer works in international human rights law, her experience at the United Nations, Harvard Kennedy School of Government, and in racial equity informs her approach to reproductive autonomy. Her passion for birth justice is rooted in centering traditional midwifery and building local, sustainable communities. Joyell’s core beliefs are that birth work is an ancestral art form and that midwifery is a blueprint for liberation. After sitting with griots and elders on 5 continents, Joyell founded Wombs of Wata, a birth worker residency that sits at the intersection of birth justice, preservation, and sustainability. Learn more about her work by visiting her website and following her on social media @themangrovemidwife.